When does terminate get called?

2014-11-13 13:22:12 +0000

In Erlang, in a gen_server, when does terminate get called? Also, some messing around with dbg for tracing.

tl;dr: if your process is trapping exits, terminate is called for everything except exit(Pid, kill).


Let’s start with a simple gen_server. See this gist for the boilerplate.

Then, in the Erlang shell:

1> c(example_server).
{ok, example_server}
2> {ok, Pid} = example_server:start_link().
{ok, <0.48.0>}
3> exit(Pid, kill).
** exception exit: killed

There’s nothing surprising there: we sent an exit signal (with kill) to the process. It died, which killed the shell process.


In order to see if terminate is called, we’re going to either need some tracing (via dbg) or some logging (which means writing some code).

Roger flips a coin

Tracing it is. So, starting from the beginning, we have:

1> c(example_server).
{ok, example_server}
2> dbg:start().
3> dbg:tracer().
4> dbg:tp(example_server, []).
5> dbg:p(all, c).
6> {ok, Pid} = example_server:start_link().
(<0.33.0>) call example_server:start_link()
(<0.47.0>) call example_server:init([])

We can turn on a bunch more tracing for that process with the following.

7> dbg:p(Pid, [c,m,p]).

Do not specify all for the process here…

And we can see that’s working, because:

8> Pid ! hello.
(<0.47.0>) << hello
(<0.47.0>) call example_server:handle_info(hello,undefined)

And, if we send it an exit signal, specifying normal:

9> exit(Pid, normal)

OK, let’s try it the hard way:

10> exit(Pid, kill).  
(<0.47.0>) exit killed
(<0.47.0>) unregister example_server


But terminate didn’t get called, because we’re not trapping exits. See process_flag. To trap exits in a gen_server:

init([]) ->
    process_flag(trap_exit, true),
    State = undefined,
    {ok, State}.

If we’re trapping exits, we see, for example:

9> exit(Pid, normal).
(<0.48.0>) << {'EXIT',<0.33.0>,normal}
(<0.48.0>) call example_server:terminate(normal,undefined)
(<0.48.0>) exit normal
(<0.48.0>) unregister example_server

Exit reasons

What about other exit reasons?

What’s going on here is that:

  1. The exit signals (apart from kill) are converted to {'EXIT', From, Reason} messages.
  2. The gen_server module handles the 'EXIT' messages and calls Mod:terminate, passing the reason.
  3. After Mod:terminate has returned, the original reason is passed to exit/1, which is propagated to linked processes (usually a supervisor of some sort).


OK, so what if the process itself chooses to stop? This is a gen_server, so it’s allowed to return {stop, NewState} from the callback functions.

Add these clauses to the top of handle_call:

handle_call(stop, _From, State) ->
    {stop, normal, ok, State};
handle_call({stop, Reason}, _From, State) ->
    {stop, Reason, ok, State};

Add these clauses to the top of handle_info:

handle_info(stop, State) ->
    {stop, normal, State};
handle_info({stop, Reason}, State) ->
    {stop, Reason, State};

And, now, we can poke it with, for example:

ok = gen_server:call(example_server, {stop, hammer_time}).


What about if the process runs into a missing function clause? Or if it calls exit/1 itself?

Yes, terminate is still called.


At this point, I ran out of things to try, and I’ve come to the conclusion that, provided you’re trapping exits, terminate will be called for everything except exit(Pid, kill).